Surfshark vs ProtonVPN
Choosing the right VPN today isn’t just about hiding your IP address—it’s about safeguarding your digital life with a solution that meets your specific needs. With so many providers claiming to offer the best service, narrowing it down can feel overwhelming. That’s why today, we’re taking a closer look at two industry standouts: Surfshark and ProtonVPN.
Both services have built solid reputations for their privacy-first philosophy, advanced security measures, and growing global presence. However, despite sharing some key qualities, each targets slightly different priorities—and understanding these nuances is crucial.
In this guide, we’ll dissect their real-world performance, security practices, streaming abilities, pricing, and more—helping you confidently choose the one that best aligns with your digital lifestyle. Let’s dive in.
Table of Contents
Key points
- Surfshark is ideal for users seeking top-tier speeds, unlimited device support, and seamless access to streaming and gaming platforms—all while keeping subscription costs impressively low.
- ProtonVPN is a strong fit for those who place absolute privacy, open-source verification, and Swiss legal protections above all else, even if that means sacrificing a bit of convenience or speed.
- If your goal is simply to enjoy hassle-free, fast, and secure VPN protection across all your devices, with a no-nonsense setup and even a free starter option, there are other VPN providers that deserves a serious look.
Quick Comparison: Surfshark vs ProtonVPN
| Feature | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Price (2-year plan) | $2.29/month | $4.99/month |
| Servers Available | 3,200+ servers in 100+ countries | 3,000+ servers in 70+ countries |
| Simultaneous Connections | Unlimited | Up to 10 |
| Average Download Speed | ~780 Mbps | ~450 Mbps |
| Streaming Access | Excellent (Netflix, Disney+, BBC, Hulu) | Strong but selective (Netflix, Amazon Prime) |
| Advanced Privacy Features | Good (RAM-only servers, CleanWeb, MultiHop) | Excellent (Secure Core, full open-source apps, Swiss jurisdiction) |
| Ease of Use | Very beginner-friendly, intuitive apps | More technical, suited for privacy enthusiasts |
| Base Jurisdiction | Netherlands (14 Eyes country) | Switzerland (outside surveillance alliances) |
As you can see, Surfshark is ideal for users who value speed, ease of use, and flexibility without dealing with technical complexities.
ProtonVPN, on the other hand, stands out for its strong focus on absolute privacy, transparency, and audited security—even if it requires a bit more experience to fully benefit from it.
Shellfire VPN is a compelling alternative, as it combines the best of both worlds: it’s just as easy to use as Surfshark, yet it also prioritizes privacy with its own no-log servers located in Germany. This makes it an especially attractive choice for users seeking strong protection without compromising on convenience.
Infrastructure & Global Coverage
| Aspect | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Total Servers | 3,200+ | 3,000+ |
| Countries Covered | 100+ | 70+ |
| Specialty Servers | P2P, Static IP, MultiHop, NoBorders Mode | Secure Core (double-hop), Tor over VPN, P2P |
| Server Expansion (2024–2025) | +600 servers | +400 servers |
Surfshark impresses with a wide-reaching network of over 3,200 servers across more than 100 countries, providing users with a versatile, global footprint ideal for streaming, gaming, and bypassing regional restrictions. Its specialized servers—like MultiHop and NoBorders Mode—enhance both privacy and accessibility, particularly in restrictive environments.
ProtonVPN, while slightly smaller in geographical reach, focuses intently on security quality. Its Secure Core architecture routes traffic through ultra-secure servers in privacy-strong countries like Switzerland and Iceland before reaching the open internet. This double-hop strategy offers unparalleled protection against surveillance and targeted attacks, though sometimes at the cost of speed.
Speed & Performance
| Metric | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Average Download Speed | ~780 Mbps | ~450 Mbps |
| Average Upload Speed | 115 Mbps | 92 Mbps |
| Latency (Ping) | 35 ms | 42 ms |
| Stability Under Load | Very stable | Stable |
| Streaming Buffering | Rarely | Occasional (on long-distance servers) |
When it comes to raw speed, Surfshark pulls ahead, leveraging the WireGuard protocol to deliver average download speeds approaching 780 Mbps—a figure that supports seamless 4K streaming, rapid downloads, and lag-free gaming across continents. Its ultra-low latency also makes it highly suitable for competitive online play and real-time communications.
ProtonVPN remains a solid performer, especially on nearby servers, but activating its Secure Core feature—which routes traffic through additional privacy layers—naturally introduces a performance dip. For users who value uncompromised privacy over peak speed, this trade-off might be entirely acceptable.
Security & Privacy
| Security Feature | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption | AES-256-GCM | AES-256-GCM |
| Kill Switch | ✅ | ✅ |
| Split Tunneling | ✅ | ✅ |
| Double VPN | ✅ (MultiHop) | ✅ (Secure Core) |
| RAM-only Servers | ✅ | ✅ |
| Open-source Apps | ❌ | ✅ |
| Audited | ✅ (Cure53) | ✅ (SEC Consult) |
| Jurisdiction | Netherlands (14 Eyes) | Switzerland (privacy-strong) |
Both Surfshark and ProtonVPN implement military-grade AES-256-GCM encryption alongside essential features like kill switches and split tunneling. Surfshark strengthens its offering with MultiHop (routing traffic through multiple countries), CleanWeb ad and malware blocking, and RAM-only servers that wipe all data on reboot.
ProtonVPN, however, positions itself at the apex of transparency and verifiable privacy. Its full suite of apps is open-source and independently audited—a level of scrutiny rare among commercial VPNs. Furthermore, operating under Switzerland’s stringent privacy laws ensures an added layer of legal protection, keeping user data safely beyond the reach of surveillance alliances like the 14 Eyes.
Streaming Performance
| Platform | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Netflix | 15+ libraries, smooth 4K | 10+ libraries, good quality |
| Amazon Prime Video | Full access | Access with U.S. servers |
| Disney+ | Excellent access | Limited access |
| HBO Max | Very good performance | Good, but inconsistent |
| BBC iPlayer | Reliable access | Mixed results |
| DAZN | Works well (some regions) | Limited access |
When it comes to unlocking streaming platforms, Surfshark clearly takes the crown. It reliably bypasses geo-restrictions across a broad spectrum of services, including Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime, Hulu, and BBC iPlayer. Thanks to Smart DNS integration and automatic NoBorders Mode, users can enjoy seamless 4K streaming without manual configuration or frequent server switching.
ProtonVPN offers respectable performance for Netflix and Amazon Prime users, especially when connected to U.S. servers. However, it struggles more consistently with stricter platforms like Disney+ or DAZN, where only a handful of servers manage to bypass VPN blocks reliably. If streaming versatility is a major priority, Surfshark provides a significantly smoother experience.
Looking for reliable streaming access across all devices?
Our Shellfire Box is designed to provide consistent access to your favorite streaming platforms, which can be a helpful solution if you’re experiencing issues with other VPNs.
Platform Compatibility
Both Surfshark and ProtonVPN offer robust cross-platform support, ensuring you can secure almost any device you own:
- ✅ Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, Amazon Fire TV
- ✅ Browser extensions for Chrome, Firefox, Edge
- ⚠️ Router configurations (manual setup for ProtonVPN; pre-configured options available for Surfshark)
Surfshark stands out with easier deployment across unconventional platforms like Smart TVs, gaming consoles, and even devices that don’t natively support VPNs, often through Smart DNS or via its straightforward router installation guides. Additionally, Surfshark offers apps for platforms like Android TV and FireStick, making it highly accessible for home entertainment setups.
ProtonVPN, while offering excellent core device support, requires more manual configuration for advanced setups, such as gaming consoles or non-Android Smart TVs. This can be a slight hurdle for users who prefer a plug-and-play experience.
User Experience & Apps
| Category | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Interface Style | Modern, minimalistic | Professional, technical |
| Setup Time | 3 minutes | 5-7 minutes |
| Customization | Basic (easy toggles) | Advanced (granular settings) |
| Mobile App Experience | Smooth, very intuitive | Secure, slightly complex |
Surfshark is a great pick if you want something quick and easy. Its clean, user-friendly apps make getting started simple—no need to deal with complex settings. Whether you’re on your phone or computer, everything works smoothly right out of the box.
ProtonVPN is more tailored to tech-savvy users who like to fine-tune their setup. It gives you more control over things like connection protocols and advanced features like Secure Core. That’s great if you know what you’re doing, but it might feel a bit much if you’re just starting out.
If you’re looking for a middle ground, Shellfire VPN is worth a look. It’s just as easy to use as Surfshark, but puts a stronger focus on privacy—with its own no-log servers based in Germany. It’s a solid choice for anyone who wants real protection without having to dig into the technical side.
Performance in Censorship-Heavy Countries
| Country | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| China | Good with NoBorders Mode | Good (requires manual config) |
| United Arab Emirates | Reliable | Mixed results |
| Russia | Good | Mixed results |
| Iran | Works well | Requires manual tweaking |
Surfshark is particularly well-suited for users in censorship-heavy countries, thanks to its NoBorders Mode. This feature automatically detects restrictive networks and adjusts connection protocols to bypass firewalls without requiring manual intervention. It performs reliably in notoriously restrictive regions such as China, Iran, the UAE, and Russia, maintaining access where many VPNs fail.
ProtonVPN also provides access in censored regions, but often demands more manual configuration, such as custom protocol selections and advanced profile setups. While it remains a strong option for technically skilled users determined to maintain access, casual users may find Surfshark’s automated approach more practical and stress-free.
Customer Support
| Aspect | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Live Chat | 24/7 (under 2 minutes) | Business hours only |
| Knowledge Base | Extensive and user-friendly | Moderate, more technical |
| Setup Tutorials | Step-by-step guides and video tutorials | Technical documentation |
| Email Response Time | ~6 hours | ~12 hours |
Effective customer support can be a crucial differentiator, especially when troubleshooting unexpected connection issues or configuring complex setups. In this regard, Surfshark offers a highly responsive 24/7 live chat support service, with average wait times under two minutes. Its knowledge base is well-organized, featuring clear, step-by-step articles and video tutorials that cater to both beginners and advanced users.
ProtonVPN provides solid support but with some limitations. Live chat is not available; instead, users must rely on email support, which typically responds within 12 hours. Its knowledge base leans more technical, requiring a higher degree of familiarity with networking concepts. While comprehensive, it may not feel as accessible for users new to VPNs.
Additional Features
| Feature | Surfshark | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Ad Blocker | ✅ (CleanWeb) | ✅ (NetShield) |
| MultiHop / Double VPN | ✅ | ✅ |
| Dedicated IP Option | ✅ (paid) | ✅ (paid) |
| Secure Streaming Mode | ✅ | ❌ |
| Open-Source Clients | ❌ | ✅ |
Surfshark includes CleanWeb, an effective ad, tracker, and malware blocker that works directly through the VPN connection—eliminating the need for separate browser extensions. It also offers a Secure Streaming Mode to optimize access to difficult-to-unlock streaming platforms, and MultiHop connections for users who want to route traffic through two countries for added anonymity. Additionally, Surfshark provides an optional Dedicated IP service for users who need a consistent IP address.
ProtonVPN focuses its feature set on uncompromising privacy. Its full suite of apps is open-source and audited, offering rare transparency. The Secure Core multi-hop feature significantly strengthens your online footprint against traffic correlation attacks. Like Surfshark, ProtonVPN also offers a Dedicated IP as a paid add-on, but it lacks some convenience-oriented features like a dedicated streaming mode.
VPN Use Cases: Best Options for Streaming, Gaming, Torrenting & More
| Use Case | Winner | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| Streaming | Surfshark | Broader platform access, smoother 4K playback, Smart DNS integration |
| Torrenting | Surfshark | Higher speeds, P2P-optimized servers, port forwarding option |
| Gaming | Surfshark | Lower ping, more stable long-distance connections |
| Privacy/Anonymity | ProtonVPN | Secure Core routing, open-source apps, Swiss privacy laws |
| Budget Option | Surfshark | Lower monthly price, unlimited device connections |
| Ease of Use | Surfshark | Intuitive setup, user-friendly apps across all devices |
| Censorship Evasion | Surfshark | NoBorders Mode automates access under restrictions |
Best VPN for Streaming
If streaming is your top priority, Surfshark is the stronger choice. It reliably unlocks over 15 Netflix libraries, plus Disney+, Prime Video, Hulu, and more—without sacrificing speed or video quality. Features like Smart DNS and Secure Streaming Mode make it easy to enjoy 4K content without tweaking settings.
ProtonVPN works well with Netflix and Prime Video in the U.S., but has trouble with tougher platforms like Disney+ and DAZN. It’s decent for basic streaming, but not the most flexible option.
For a more plug-and-play approach, our Shellfire Box stands out. It connects directly to your router, bringing VPN protection to all your devices—including smart TVs and consoles—with zero configuration. It’s ideal for hassle-free streaming across your entire home.
Best VPN for Torrenting
Surfshark is a strong choice for torrenting. It has P2P-optimized servers, fast speeds, and even offers optional port forwarding to boost downloads and seeding.
It also keeps your activity private with a strict no-logs policy and RAM-only servers, so nothing is stored after you disconnect.
ProtonVPN supports torrents too, but speeds can drop when using Secure Core. It’s a privacy-focused option, though less convenient for heavy file sharing.
Best VPN for Gaming
For gaming, Surfshark is the better pick. It offers low latency (around 35 ms), stable connections, and minimal packet loss—even over long distances—making it great for fast-paced online games.
While ProtonVPN is secure, its Secure Core feature can slow things down, which isn’t ideal when timing is everything.
Best VPN for Privacy and Anonymity
Privacy-focused users will feel right at home with ProtonVPN. Based in Switzerland and fully open-source, it offers unmatched legal protections and transparency.
Secure Core routes your traffic through multiple servers for extra security—perfect for journalists or those in high-surveillance areas.
Surfshark also does well, with RAM-only servers and no-logs policies. But if maximum privacy is your priority, ProtonVPN goes a step further.
Best VPN for Budget-Conscious Users
Surfshark offers great value. For just a couple of dollars a month, you get full features and unlimited devices—ideal for families or users with lots of gadgets.
ProtonVPN has solid features too, but costs more and limits you to 10 devices. It’s a better fit for privacy over price.
Best VPN for Ease of Use
Surfshark is incredibly user-friendly. Its apps are clean, simple, and consistent across devices—perfect if you’re new to VPNs or just want something that works.
ProtonVPN’s interface is polished too, but leans toward advanced users who like to tinker with settings. Not ideal if you just want to connect and go.
Best VPN for Censorship Evasion
Surfshark’s NoBorders Mode kicks in automatically on restricted networks. It’s great for traveling or living in countries with heavy censorship like China or Iran.
ProtonVPN can bypass blocks too, but usually needs manual tweaks and setup. Surfshark offers a simpler, more reliable solution for staying connected.
Conclusion
Both Surfshark and ProtonVPN are excellent VPN options, but they serve different needs. Surfshark stands out for its speed, ease of use, and affordability. With unlimited device support and reliable access to streaming platforms, it’s a great fit for everyday users, families, travelers, and anyone who values a smooth, no-fuss experience across all devices.
ProtonVPN, on the other hand, is built for those who prioritize privacy above all else. With Swiss jurisdiction, open-source apps, and its Secure Core technology, it provides a high level of security and transparency. It’s especially suited for journalists, activists, or users operating in high-risk environments—but it may require more technical confidence and comes at a higher price point.
Still undecided? Shellfire VPN is a smart middle-ground. It offers strong privacy, user-friendly apps, and even a free plan to get started. And with the Shellfire Box, you can protect every device in your home—without installing anything. It’s a practical solution for users who want real protection, minus the complexity.
