Private Internet Access vs ProtonVPN
When choosing a VPN, the right fit depends not just on what it can do, but on how well it complements your habits and expectations. In this detailed comparison of Private Internet Access (PIA) and ProtonVPN, we explore two standout services that approach digital protection from very different angles.
PIA offers robust customization and affordability for those who enjoy tuning their setup. ProtonVPN, meanwhile, champions simplicity and trust, backed by Swiss privacy laws and a strong reputation for transparency. This guide helps you weigh their merits and see where alternate options, like hardware-based VPNs, might also offer long-term advantages.
Table of Contents
Key Points
- Private Internet Access (PIA) stands out with powerful configuration options, competitive pricing, and no device limits, ideal for users who want complete control over their VPN experience.
- ProtonVPN leverages Swiss jurisdiction, Secure Core double-hop routing, and a strict no-logs policy to deliver enhanced privacy and legal protection, perfect for users needing the strongest anonymity guarantees.
- Alternative VPN categories like plug-and-play routers or easy-to-use apps serve those who prioritize simplicity, family-wide protection, or hassle-free connectivity across all home devices.
Quick Comparison: Private Internet Access vs ProtonVPN
| Feature | Private Internet Access (PIA) | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Price (long-term) | ≈ $2.19/mo (annual)–$11.99/mo (monthly) | ≈ $4.99/mo (annual)–$12.99/mo (monthly) |
| Server Locations | 35,000+ servers in 90+ countries | 1,900+ servers in 65+ countries |
| Simultaneous Connections | Unlimited | 10 devices (Free: 1) |
| Encryption & Protocols | OpenVPN, WireGuard, AES-256 | OpenVPN, IKEv2, WireGuard, AES-256 |
| No-logs Policy | Audited, based in the US | Audited, based in Switzerland |
| Streaming & P2P | Works with Netflix, Disney+, P2P-friendly | Works with Netflix, Disney+, more limited P2P |
| Kill Switch | Yes (App-level and System-wide) | Yes (App-level and System-wide) |
| Special Features | Split tunneling, port forwarding, MACE ad-blocker | Secure Core, Tor over VPN, integrated ad-blocking |
Both VPNs deliver secure encryption, system-wide kill switches, and support for high-speed WireGuard. PIA is the go-to choice for users who crave vast server networks and tools for customization. ProtonVPN, meanwhile, leads with privacy-first design, robust server integrity, and a strategic jurisdictional base. If your top concern is legal resilience and digital anonymity, ProtonVPN has an edge. For pure speed and flexibility at a better price point, PIA makes a compelling case.
Alternatively, Shellfire VPN offers a lightweight, easy-to-use interface and fast setup, making it especially appealing for users who prefer a simple, effective solution without digging into advanced configurations. Its straightforward pricing and accessible apps make it a sensible option for those prioritizing convenience and reliable protection across devices.
Infrastructure & Global Coverage
| Metric | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Server Count | 35,000+ (self-hosted & virtual) | 1,900+ (all self-hosted) |
| Countries | 90+ | 65+ |
| Residential IPs | No | Limited Secure Core exit IPs |
| Virtual Servers | Yes (helps expand region access) | Minimal; focuses on self-hosted real hardware |
PIA offers an extensive server network that spans over 90 countries. With over 35,000 servers, including virtual ones, users can find optimal routing for almost any region. ProtonVPN, on the other hand, emphasizes infrastructure transparency. Every server is physically controlled, ensuring reliable, tamper-proof performance. This approach benefits users who want auditable, dependable connectivity, even if the total number of servers is smaller.
Speed & Performance
| Metric | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| WireGuard Download | ≈ 600–700 Mbps | ≈ 500–600 Mbps |
| WireGuard Upload | ≈ 300–400 Mbps | ≈ 250–350 Mbps |
| Latency (EU–US) | ~90 ms | ~100 ms |
| Consistency | Good (variable on crowded servers) | Very good (fewer users per server) |
PIA consistently reaches impressive speeds, making it an excellent pick for streaming, large downloads, or gaming. ProtonVPN performs just slightly behind in terms of peak performance, but delivers more consistent throughput due to its lower server density. If you value predictable, reliable performance over top-end speed, ProtonVPN’s design is a smart bet.
For users chasing the fastest numbers, PIA wins this round. You can also see how PIA stacks up against NordVPN in direct speed tests for more context.
Security & Privacy
| Feature | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption | AES‑256, RSA‑4096, SHA‑256 | AES‑256, RSA‑4096, SHA‑384 |
| Protocols | OpenVPN, WireGuard | OpenVPN, IKEv2/IPSec, WireGuard |
| Jurisdiction | USA (subject to data requests) | Switzerland (strong privacy laws) |
| No‑logs Policy | Independently audited, no logs | Independently audited, no logs |
| Advanced Privacy | MACE ad‑blocker, port forwarding | Secure Core, Tor+VPN, Secure Core exit IPs |
When it comes to security, both VPNs use leading encryption standards and support trusted tunneling protocols. However, their approaches diverge in legal context. PIA, being US-based, could legally face government requests, even if their no-logs policy protects users from actual data exposure. ProtonVPN benefits from Switzerland’s strict privacy legislation, giving it a strategic edge for users in surveillance-heavy regions or those needing maximum legal resilience. Secure Core and Tor-over-VPN are compelling additions for those requiring layered anonymity.
Users interested in how ProtonVPN compares in terms of privacy with other major providers might also want to look at this side-by-side analysis with NordVPN.
Streaming Performance
| Platform | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Netflix | Works reliably, HD/4K | Works well, HD; occasional geolocation issues |
| Disney+ | Strong support | Good support; sometimes limited to HQ servers |
| Amazon Prime Video | Generally reliable | Moderate reliability |
| HBO Max / Max | Good | Good |
For streaming enthusiasts, PIA delivers wider compatibility across platforms and resolutions. It handles geoblocked content effectively and works smoothly with Netflix, Prime Video, and more. ProtonVPN also unlocks key platforms but may occasionally face regional restrictions that require switching to higher-tier servers. Still, it offers a robust experience for users who prioritize privacy but enjoy occasional streaming.
Looking for reliable streaming access across all devices?
Our Shellfire Box is designed to provide consistent access to your favorite streaming platforms, which can be a helpful solution if you’re experiencing issues with other VPNs.
Platform Compatibility
| Device / OS | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Windows, macOS, Linux | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| iOS, Android | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Routers | Custom firmware & guides | Manual OpenVPN/config support |
| Browser Extensions | Chrome, Firefox (MACE included) | None yet |
| Streaming Devices & Consoles | Via router or desktop apps | Via router or desktop apps |
Both VPNs offer broad platform support, covering all major operating systems and devices. PIA has the edge with dedicated browser extensions and more detailed router support. This makes it easier to configure across multi-device households or setups needing advanced customization. ProtonVPN supports all core platforms and functions well in typical use cases, but may lack the plug-in options some users desire.
Performance in Censorship-Heavy Countries
| Country/Region | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| China | Limited success; manual config needed | Moderate; Secure Core may help |
| Iran | Mixed; OpenVPN manual setup | Better; Secure Core can bypass blocks |
| Russia | OK with custom ports | Strong with Secure Core |
ProtonVPN offers more reliable access in countries with restrictive firewalls thanks to its Secure Core and Tor-over-VPN modes. These tools improve anonymity and unblock content without extensive user tweaks. PIA can work in these areas, but often requires manual adjustments, such as custom port settings and OpenVPN configuration, making it more suitable for experienced users who don’t mind fine-tuning.
User Experience & Apps
| Criterion | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| UI Design | Clean, customizable; advanced settings | Modern, minimalistic, beginner-friendly |
| Ease of Use | Medium; power-user orientation | High; ideal for non-technical users |
| App Stability | Stable; occasional glitches on new updates | Very stable; focus on polished UX |
| Advanced Options | Rich (split tunnel, port forwarding, MACE) | Selective (Secure Core toggle, Tor-over-VPN) |
PIA is tailored for experienced users, offering layered settings and advanced toggles for fine-tuning. It’s an ideal choice for those who enjoy full control over how their VPN operates. ProtonVPN delivers a more polished and intuitive experience, suitable for newcomers or users seeking a more hands-off approach. Its interface is clean, accessible, and doesn’t sacrifice functionality despite its simplified layout.
Still, users seeking true plug-and-play simplicity might lean toward the Shellfire Box. Its hardware-based model secures every device on a home network without requiring manual installations or software updates. This makes it particularly appealing for households with mixed device ecosystems or users who value a consistent, no-fuss setup across all connections.
Customer Support
| Support Feature | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Live Chat | 24/7 (via ticket system) | Live chat & email; business hours |
| Email Response Time | ~6–12 hrs | ~2–6 hrs |
| Knowledge Base | Extensive guides & community | Detailed articles & FAQs |
| Community Forum | Active user forum | Limited forum; support via community |
Both VPNs offer quality support, though their strengths vary. ProtonVPN is faster to respond via email and features live chat during business hours, which is especially helpful for real-time issues. PIA leans on its user community and detailed documentation, which is particularly helpful for those who prefer DIY solutions or need advanced setup support at unconventional hours.
Additional Features
| Feature | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Port Forwarding | Yes | No |
| Ad/Malware Blocking | MACE built-in | Integrated tracker/adblock on desktops |
| Multi-hop | No | Secure Core (multi-hop) |
| Tor Support | Manual use | One-click Tor-over-VPN |
| Split Tunneling | Yes | No |
PIA gives users granular control over VPN behavior, especially useful for tasks like torrenting, remote access, or ad-blocking. ProtonVPN prioritizes seamless advanced protection with simplified tools like Secure Core and Tor-over-VPN. For users needing maximum simplicity with minimal manual tuning, ProtonVPN’s feature set hits the mark. Those wanting customizable functionality will find PIA more fitting.
However, for users less focused on granular controls and more interested in securing their entire network from a central point, the Shellfire Box presents a distinct advantage. Its combination of ad-blocking, DNS protection, and centralized configuration brings enterprise-style VPN utility to personal households without the complexity.
VPN Use Cases: Best Options for Streaming, Gaming, Torrenting & More
| Use Case | PIA | ProtonVPN |
|---|---|---|
| Streaming | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Torrenting / P2P | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Gaming | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Remote Work | ⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Budget-Conscious | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐ |
| Censorship-Heavy Countries | ⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
Best VPN for Streaming
For frequent streamers, PIA delivers dependable access to Netflix, Disney+, HBO Max, and Amazon Prime Video across multiple regions with high-definition or 4K playback. Its vast server pool ensures minimal buffering and easy regional switching. ProtonVPN is a strong alternative but may occasionally require switching to higher-tier servers or Secure Core nodes to maintain access, making it slightly less seamless for continuous binge-watching.
That said, Shellfire VPN has demonstrated solid streaming performance on popular platforms, particularly in European regions. While it may not offer the same advanced configuration options, its reliability and ease of use can be a welcome alternative for users who want quick access to entertainment without fussing with settings or server switches.
Best VPN for Torrenting / P2P
PIA excels for torrenting, offering key features like port forwarding, split tunneling, and unlimited simultaneous connections. Combined with fast WireGuard speeds, it’s an ideal option for heavy downloaders and users managing multiple file-sharing sessions. ProtonVPN supports P2P but only on select servers and without port forwarding, making it better suited for occasional, privacy-focused torrenting rather than consistent use.
Best VPN for Gaming
Gamers will appreciate PIA for its low-latency WireGuard performance, customizable ports, and device flexibility. Whether gaming on PC, console, or mobile, the performance remains sharp and stable. ProtonVPN is a reliable option for long gaming sessions where consistency matters more than ultra-low ping, though it lacks advanced customization features.
Alternatively, the Shellfire Box can be a smart solution for gaming households, especially when multiple consoles and smart devices share the same network. Its ability to protect the entire home connection with one setup reduces the need for individual installations and keeps latency in check by routing all traffic efficiently through its optimized servers.
Best VPN for Remote Work
Remote professionals handling confidential data will benefit from ProtonVPN’s Secure Core architecture, which routes traffic through privacy-focused jurisdictions, adding another shield of anonymity. Its jurisdiction in Switzerland makes it especially appealing for users in surveillance-sensitive industries. While PIA also offers stable connections for telework, its US location may concern those requiring maximum legal protection.
Best VPN for Budget-Conscious Users
PIA clearly takes the lead for users watching their spending, offering one of the lowest prices in the industry with no limit on devices. It’s well-suited for households, students, or tech-savvy users managing multiple systems. ProtonVPN justifies its higher price with advanced privacy features, but for those who prioritize affordability over anonymity layers, PIA is the smarter pick.
Best VPN for Censorship-Heavy Countries
ProtonVPN is a strong choice for users in regions with heavy censorship, offering tools like Secure Core and Tor-over-VPN that are built for bypassing firewalls and preserving access. It’s particularly valuable for activists, journalists, or users in authoritarian regimes. PIA can work in these environments with manual setups and advanced tweaks, but it requires a higher level of technical know-how.
Conclusion
Private Internet Access and ProtonVPN both rank among the top VPN services for good reason, but they cater to slightly different needs. PIA delivers affordability, high performance, and powerful customization, making it ideal for tech-savvy users, streamers, and torrenters. ProtonVPN, meanwhile, shines with strong privacy ethics, a Swiss legal foundation, and tools built for anonymity, making it an excellent pick for security-focused individuals.
Ultimately, your choice depends on what matters most: if you want total control and great value, go with PIA; if privacy and jurisdictional strength are your top priorities, ProtonVPN is the better fit.
That said, for users seeking a simpler, more universal approach to digital protection, the Shellfire VPN and Shellfire Box are excellent alternatives. These options combine user-friendly design with effective security, ideal for families or households looking for effortless, whole-home protection. With both software and hardware solutions, Shellfire offers plug-and-play peace of mind for every connected device.
